Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I have a cross slide that I have cleaned up pretty well.  Operation is smooth.  However, there is "slack" in all of the controls.  Perhaps several hundred microns.  Looking at the design, there does not appear to me that there was any design feature to null this out.  I have other precision microscope slides that have a feature to eliminate any slack.  My guess is that the design is such that you only expect calibrated movement when going in just one direction.

Any thoughts on this?

Am I the only one who has noticed?

BTW, at first when I got it working, I did not appreciate its purpose.  Now I recognize one very important purpose is truing a metal rod that is out of round.  This seems very hard by hand with a graver, but quite easy using the cross slide.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's normal, even a new slide might have 2-3 hundredths of play in the screw. Most small slides have an adjustment for the "bearing", usually a cylindrical portion of the screw near the crank which is captured in the slide mount with a nut, this can be brought until there is near zero play and the screw is still free. Often some of the play that's perceived as between the nut and screw is actually there.

 

More modern slides, like later Levin and larger ones will have preloaded ball bearings here, smooth action with no play.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, nickelsilver said:

Correct, there is no provision to take up play between the screw and nut. So you always approach from the same direction, taking up the slack before. With a good slide, with hundredths of mm of slack, no problem working to microns.

Thanks a bunch...this make me feel better!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The correct term for what you are describing is called backlash.

When I did my apprenticeship, I was fortunate to work on some of the more high end lathes in the workshop. All of them had backlash. Some more than others.

Mill had backlash. Horizontal borer had backlash.

I am not aware of watchmakers lathes and the cross slides as to whether you could move the measurement scale on the slide after you have taken up the backlash. We could do that on the larger machines.

I am not aware of newer machines these days, but in the eighties, if you wanted to get a machine that had backlash adjustment capability, break out your cheque book.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

Correct, there is no provision to take up play between the screw and nut. So you always approach from the same direction, taking up the slack before. With a good slide, with hundredths of mm of slack, no problem working to microns.

For the OP or anyone that has never done or is just at the beginning with lathe or milling work. 

The approach above is the way to follow if you have only the wheel dials to rely on, possibly of the non-zearoable type to add pain. But as soon you back off "the controls", voluntarily or not, then returning precisely to the same point just "taking up the slack" does not work anymore. In other words, using dials on the wheels you can't measure distance in both directions, and kind of fastidiously in one direction only.

The solution is simply to use an instrument (dial indicator) which tells where your tool holder or workpiece is, on whatever axis you apply it. It does't know or care about backlash, nut play, double nuts, ball bearings, or anything else.  It saves you from remembering how much a division on the wheel is, if it doubles for diameter or not, or having to convert from metric to inches. You can get one including mag base and arm for about USD20. 

DSC_0426_copy_800x551.jpg.9a61ebfd5499c41fd5b079dd91afe541.jpg

Truth is however,  real watchmaking work on a watchmaker's lathe do not use dials, indicators and not even slides or wheels mostly. Just gravers, handfeeling, loupe and micrometer. But as my mentor says, better start learning on the large and get to the smaller gradually. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, jdm said:

For the OP or anyone that has never done or is just at the beginning with lathe or milling work. 

The approach above is the way to follow if you have only the wheel dials to rely on, possibly of the non-zearoable type to add pain. But as soon you back off "the controls", voluntarily or not, then returning precisely to the same point just "taking up the slack" does not work anymore. In other words, using dials on the wheels you can't measure distance in both directions, and kind of fastidiously in one direction only.

The solution is simply to use an instrument (dial indicator) which tells where your tool holder or workpiece is, on whatever axis you apply it. It does't know or care about backlash, nut play, double nuts, ball bearings, or anything else.  It saves you from remembering how much a division on the wheel is, if it doubles for diameter or not, or having to convert from metric to inches. You can get one including mag base and arm for about USD20. 

DSC_0426_copy_800x551.jpg.9a61ebfd5499c41fd5b079dd91afe541.jpg

Truth is however,  real watchmaking work on a watchmaker's lathe do not use dials, indicators and not even slides or wheels mostly. Just gravers, handfeeling, loupe and micrometer. But as my mentor says, better start learning on the large and get to the smaller gradually. 

I ordered this setup in addition to a runout indicator gauge.  Just for kicks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • A already know the size movement I have the problem is the dial a had purchased has a dimension 20.6mm wide a want to find a watch case that going to fit the dial perfectly 
    • Hi.  I would like to take issue here regarding battery driven , watches, clocks,etc. I will and do repair these clocks in fact I have sever al in my collection as well as the regular mechanical ones. I have one on my mantle piece over 60 years old tha belonged to my wife’s Aunt,  long gone Iam afraid and it has been cleaned etc and never missed a beat and is accurate. Every one has their preduices as regards Electrical /electronic Horology but I regard it as part of the progress time line of the art of Horology and to be treated as such. Like Darwin’s theory of evolution it evolved.  Two cavemen knocking rocks together and a shard broke off , looking at it he worked out if it was stuck on the end of a stick he would have a spear. Likewise his pal seeing what he was up to picked up a piece  and did the same, now that’s evolution. Some clockmaker decided to build a clock that ran with a battery and no spring to wind up and break, progress and both the mechanical and battery driven clocks evolved, the battery ones got better to the point that if it broke you changed the complete unit. Likewise watches did the same but both can be repaired by people who approach Horology with an open mind without preduice.  We all have our likes and dislikes bu I for one would never dismiss any technology because I don’t like it.   The mobile phone is a good example of modern technology at work as is the automotive industry. There buttons and switches in my car I don’t use because to me they are not nesessary but I still drive the car.
    • I haven't gone through all the reading of what it might be or not. The first thing I would do if nothing obvious stands out is replace the mainspring, you have to start at the source of the power. Nine times out of ten that is the problem.  
    • Haha. You're just in a wicked mood today John 😅
    • Heres my watch of today, a Smith 13'" RY . My missus bought me this for this Valentines day a bargain 14.99 with a reduction, the seller has occasional 20% off offers now and then so it was about 15ish with delivery. I love Smiths and i love bulleye dials, this is my first one. The watch arrived non working as stated and i knew what was inside and what would be against me, but i enjoy a challenge, we dont expect a lot if anything from pin pallet movements. A balance pivot was broken and i didnt have another staff but i did have another RY with a battered dial so i robbed the balance and tweaked it around to make it work apart from that mostly just a good clean and relubrication. Keyless works are pretty rough by design and the crown is a bugger to get in and out with the dial on, the setting lever hits the dial before it releases it, so a little mod is needed to help that along. Major problem was the pins on the lever were quite worn which make the old tg have a snow storm fit. Its a similar read for most pin pallets, these were brass as was the escape wheel. But perseverance is me, i didn't change the pins but i did spend some time dressing and polishing the worn areas which improved the trace a lot with some straightish lines 😅 and a beat error of .5 . Not sure what the lift angle should be on these and i Wasn't in the mood to work it out and who believes timegraphers anyway, but at the default 52° it runs with 260ish full 210 after 24 hours dial down , the verticals rates were pretty much all over place. So lets just put it in it's superlight aluminium case and see what happens. Been wearing it now for 3 weeks and it's consistently losing around 1.5  minutes a week winding each morning i think pretty good for an old pin pallet watch. I just love this dial, thanks wifey heres my Valentine's gift for yer sweetie x
×
×
  • Create New...