Jump to content

Faulty Seiko NH35a, any guess?


Recommended Posts

Hi everyone,

I am digging into mechanical watches internals because of a faulty Chinese submariner clone that I want to repair.

I have disassembled the whole watch and I think the problem is in the pallet fork. Entry pallet seems too short although it seems OK from the pictures:

20201025_153316.thumb.jpg.e523dbad54ec44dbd470e9e179052775.jpg

And here is the video of the behavior:

 

What guys do think about it? Should I replace the pallet fork or am I missing something else during reassembly?

 

 

 

 

20201025_153445.jpg

20201025_153544.jpg

20201025_153843.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you post some more pictures of this movement. Finishing seems downright horrible, escape wheel is stained, the visible portion of the hairspring is distorted. In fairness now is too late to return it, if your goal is simply to complete the watch I would get another mov.t from a reputable seller and not spend more good money after bad.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sure here some more; although I have reassemble the watch this afternoon. I don't have much.

Since I am learning, this is more of a study movement and I made some scratches in some places.

I can order a new nh35 for 25€, or order a palette fork + club wheel for 8 € (from ebay). So I am hesitating.

From your experience, what could cause this issue?

20201025_153512.jpg

20201025_154201.jpg

20201025_153544.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi! 

From your video, it appears as if the escape wheel tooth is not locking into the entry stone. The exit stone appears to lock appropriately. Several things to consider. 

  1. Broken or chipped entry pallet stone. 
  2. Loose entry pallet stone. 
  3. Malpositioned entry pallet stone (not making contact with the escape wheel teeth in the locking phase). 
  4. Entry lever/arm of the pallet fork is bent. 
  5. Too much endshake in the escape wheel (on the video it appears as if the escape wheel has a significant upwards vertical shift when spinning). 

I do have some other questions...

  • The movement seems significantly tarnished. Is this an original NH35, or a clone? 
  • Did this happen all of a sudden, or was the watch functioning properly beforehand? Did it happen before or after disassembly? 

In regards to your question about buying a new movement. I would recommend you do, especially considering that the NH35 is a relatively inexpensive movement. 

Best of luck! 

Guido

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, DrG said:

do have some other questions...

  • The movement seems significantly tarnished. Is this an original NH35, or a clone? 
  • Did this happen all of a sudden, or was the watch functioning properly beforehand? Did it happen before or after disassembly? 

Thank you all for your replies.

The movement comes from a Pagani Design submariner homage : PD-1661. I hope it is a genuine NH35a but really not sure about that. Here are some more pictures of the watch.

The watch stopped working (movement was stuck) after 1 day of wearing it. So I decided to dig into it instead of returning it with a 5% chance of being reimbursed...

During the disassembly, I was searching for the issue when suddenly all the power reserved get out of the mainspring with a high speed gear noise when checking the escape wheel. (the balanced wheel was removed, but not the pallet fork). I thought that I had found the issue so I decided to reassemble it and here I am.

I need to check but maybe, it is the bottom jewel of the escape wheel that moved and is making it too low for the entry pallet to block its movement. I will maybe disassemble the dial of the watch and the train wheels to inspect it again.

Thanks again for your tips

20201026_125314.jpg

20201026_125343.jpg

20201026_125400.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, beastiole said:

During the disassembly, I was searching for the issue when suddenly all the power reserved get out of the mainspring with a high speed gear noise when checking the escape wheel. (the balanced wheel was removed, but not the pallet fork).

Was the pallet secured in place with the pallet bridge when the mainspring unwound suddenly or was the bridge removed or loose?  Since all the mainspring power was suddenly let down, you have to check for broken pivots in the escape wheel as well as in the pallet. 

1 hour ago, beastiole said:

I need to check but maybe, it is the bottom jewel of the escape wheel that moved and is making it too low for the entry pallet to block its movement.

If this is the case you will need a jeweling tool in order to get the lower escape wheel jewel back in place.

If the entry pallet jewel is out of place, it can be moved, but you will need to measure the appropriate distance from the escape wheel tooth in both the locking phase and impulse phase. This can be done "by eye" or with a dedicated measuring tool. You will also need to learn how to work Shellac in order to adjust that jewel. ?

Your enthusiasm for solving this problem is wonderful!! Even if you buy a new movement (which is my recommendation), keep working on this one until you find the problem. It's the best way to learn in watch repair and watch making. 

Regards, 

Guido

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Could you zoom in and get a higher magnification photo of the pallet fork?

In your second photo of the pallet fork, it appears that the pallet fork has a stress fracture where the arbor goes through the fork arms. Or is it a giant scratch from poor finishing. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, HectorLooi said:

Could you zoom in and get a higher magnification photo of the pallet fork?

In your second photo of the pallet fork, it appears that the pallet fork has a stress fracture where the arbor goes through the fork arms. Or is it a giant scratch from poor finishing. 

looks like reflection to me...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Hi there,

(pictures are not really good and deformed as they are taken using a smartphone with a 8x numerical zoom)

After some investigations, I found what was the cause of the pallet fork not stopping the escapement wheel.

I initially ordered a pallet fork + escapement wheel (sold together) in the objective of replacing the pallet fork .

I compared them but they looked similar: (forged the visible fiber in the newer on the left)

20201103_215751.thumb.jpg.748f4097ae7ecf4bf82c8801c322a350.jpg

I them inspected the movement and tried understand where the problem should lie, and decided to record a video with my phone to see something as I didn't own a magnifier / microscope.

So I removed the escapement wheel and compared it with the new one that come with the pallet fork:

20201103_202645.thumb.jpg.e466f0c93bd84b7fba333b7b81696b4d.jpg

And, voilà. New one on  the left, old one on the right. You can easily spot the difference and understand why the wheel was jumping during the rotation...

I cleaned the fibers that you can see on the picture again, and installed the new one in the watch.

The movement was working again \o/ .... with not much amplitude so the watch was gaining 20sec/min.

I decided to rework the hairspring, after ordering a magnifier, and .... I damaged it ... with my tweezers ...

Fortunately, I managed to fix it and reassemble it. And now ... it works without problems \o/.

The movement still loose a min/day, but I will now try to regulate it.

Thank you.

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by beastiole
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Got another one today! It took 10 weeks, but finally arrived. Fairly complete but I added the pivot guage. The burnisher and bow came with the tool. The case is a bit rough and the tool pretty dirty, but trying to decide how much I want to restore.
    • OK, so long story short, I'm working my way through Mark's courses using a "Sea-gul ST36" (or ST3600 from some vendors) AKA an ETA 6497 clone. as a practice piece.  I've had it fully appart and cleaned it, and have had it fully back together an "running", but only briefly as my oil hadn't arrived at the time.  In the course of that work, I saw no markings on the movement that would tell me if it was a true Sea-gul or just a clone of their clone of the original ETA movement. Well, fast forward to this weekend, when my oils arrived in my mailbox and I sat down to try my hand at oiling.  Everything was going swimmingly until I got to the shock setting on the top of the balance cock.  I was able to open the lyre spring without issue, but in attempting to swing the open to access the cap jewel and chaton, I apparently accidentally pressed the launch button as I sent the lyre spring into low earth orbit.  Like most things that make into such orbits it came back down at a place not too far from where it started, but of course that also means that it is no longer in the setting. So my task is now to get said spring back into setting.  What I have read so far tells me that I seem to have two options: Another thread here seems to indicate that the spring came out without taking the balance cock apart, therefore it should go back without the need for that procedure.  That seems a bit pie in the sky for me, but the posts in said thread also gave some high level information about how to get the spring back in (putting it at an angle to the channel cut in the cock and canted so that the tabs fit in the slots, followed by some "wiggling" to get it turned around the right direction.)  I've tried this a couple of times, which have lead to more trips to low earth orbit, but with successful recovery of the orbital vehicle after each trip.  This thread also suggests that what I did to cause the initial launch was to push the spring "back" with more pressure on one side than the other, which put it under tension and caused it to deform out the slot either on one side or at the end (where there is apparently no "back stop".) The other option appears to be varying degrees of disassembly of the balance cock.  Some things I've read suggest that the whole shock setting needs to come out, while other threads here suggest that I only need to remove the regulator arm and the arm carrying the balance stud.  After the last trip the spring made, this is seeming like a better option, but I'm super short on details on how to do what needs to be done.  if I am following correctly: I need to loose the balance spring stud screw so the stud is not held in the arm. I need to somehow disengage the balance spring from the regulator (all the regulators I've seen in videos look nothing like what I see on the balance cock I have.)  What I've seen on the interwebs is a couple of "pins" that the spring passes through.  What I see on my assembly is something that looks more like a single pin with a "V" shaped notch cut in the bottom of it.  The spring is secured in that notch with something that I guessed was glue, Posts here suggest that on some of these movements glue is in fact used.  So I'm trying to figure out how to tell, how to soften dissolve it (I'm guessing IPA or acetone) and how to put it back when I'm done (superglue?  UV glue?) With the spring detached from the cock, I've read that the regulator and stud carrier are basically glorified C clamps around the shock setting and that one removes them by slipping a razor blade under one side of each and prizing them up.  I assume that they go back in the reverse manner like another C clamp, but that again is only a guess.  The place I got this information from seemed to leave that bit out. Once I have one or both arms off the shock setting the above mentioned post seemed to indicate that I could just slide the spring back in the slot, though again, I'm interpolating between the lines I read.  The alternative that I've seen demonstrated on high end movements on Youtube is to remove the entire shock setting and to replace the spring from "underneath" rotating the setting so that spring basically falls into place. I'm not anxious to try this method, as I don't have a jeweling tool to put the shock setting back into place.  That not to mention that the professional watch maker who did the demonstration described "fiddly work." So at the end of the day I'm looking for a little guidance on which pathway to follow, or if I've missed something obvious, a new direction to follow.  If this is a repair that just need to wait until my skills improve I'm totally good with that, I can get another of these movements in relatively short order, I just don't want to treat this one as disposable, and I do want to make an honest effort at fixing it and learning from this experience. Thank you in advance for reading my ramblings and for any suggestions that you might have!
    • All the best, family always comes first, and I believe you have made the right call that you mother deserves your full attention. However, when you need a little outside distraction the guys here will always be available for some banter or a heated discussion on lubrication 🤣.
    • Wire for what? if it's steel then only certain types of steel can be hardened ie high carbon steels: "Mild steel doesn't harden very well. It doesn't have enough carbon. Get something like O1, silver steel or if you want to go full watchmaker, then Sandvik 20AP". Source
    • I'm wondering if there's any specific type of wire I should get for hardening? I would assume it doesn't matter as long as the wire doesn't melt before it is at temp. 
×
×
  • Create New...