Jump to content

Stuck brass movement ring


Recommended Posts

I have a brass movement ring stuck tight. Does anyone have experience removing such with care?

It's in a old Buren auto with a Durowe 611. You can tell the ring may have been beaten in by the dimples on the top edge. I've tried to gently pry it out all around but it is soft brass. I've tried to tap around its circumference inwards to dislodge it from the case. It's pretty dirty and it does seem to be more stuck to the case than the movement itself.

I've also tried to pry it away using the stem slot, which does have a inner lip, but to no avail. I'm worried about pressing too much on the movement itself. This is the first brass one I've come across.

If it was more stuck to the movement than the case I would just apply heat to expand it, but that likely won't work for brass on brass. Would some release agent be next to try? If so, which?

Thanks in advance for any suggestions or experiences.

DSC07265.thumb.JPG.8ef7b3a3db3335fdfef0f414156e13d1.JPGDSC07266.thumb.JPG.8fecc3ba7de5e682d072240bded49c44.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don’t like that the movement is there, but you could try inverting a can of “air” to release the cold liquid onto the ring and shrink it away from the case. 
 

once it’s out, address the tight fit. Either it’s out of round or oversized. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi I would try the cold air method first or use plumbers freezing spray to try and contract the brass ring  if none available put it in the freezer for a while.  But before all that checkout Hectors assumption, It well may be a front loader as the vacant screw holes are suggestive of such. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks all for the suggestions. I'll first try contracting the ring with a can of compressed electronics duster and/or the freezer. If still stuck in there, I'll just remove the crystal to make sure it's not a front loader although there are a couple of indications it's not. I'll definitely address the fit once it's all cleaned up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I will advice to share the idea first here before doeing something to the movement
    • When you move the index which changes the timing from an extreme fast to an extreme slow, is there a big change in beat error? Obviously there will be a big change in timing. If there is a big difference in BE then this is strongly inferring the the end-curve of the hairspring isn't set correctly or/and the collet is central to the jewel on the balance cock, because the hairspring that is breathing between the curb pin and boot is being pushed and/or pulled when you move the index from left to right. Also not having the hairspring set correctly can dramatically reduce the amplitude. A quick check is to take power off the movement and move the index from extreme fast to slow and with high magnification see if the hairspring sits nicely between the curb pin and boot at all times (give the balance a spin and watch the hairspring - has it got total freedom?) or if it moves by being pushed or pulled by the curb pin or boot. I'm guessing it is the latter. I think that may be a possibility to your problem.
    • I can't get windingstens.com to open but you need a  few measurements. 
    • All Done, Here are the finished pictures: This one shows the generic "one-size-fits-all" base which accepts the bespoke rings - notice that the parametric movement OD (27.40 mm) automatically prints on the ring 🙂 From another angle: Here is the ring about to go into the base: And finally the base and ring together: Here it is next to a pen for scale: On my system with 20% fill each ring will take about 18 mins to print, but I am sure this could be optimised: Here is the screenshot of the spreadsheet in FreeCAD, you just need to change one value to create the ring in cell C3, (the base doesn't need any changes). I just uploaded the files to printables link here, but also include  here as a fake pdf, please change the .pdf to .zip to make the file work once downloaded: Modular Movement Holder.pdf Any feedback welcome!     I'm also going to make a parametric ring insert for rectangular/oval movements - but I just finished a parent teacher evening so too tired now 🙂  
×
×
  • Create New...