Jump to content

Stuck ratchet wheel screw, Unitas 285


DanB

Recommended Posts

Hi all,

Just started disassembling a Gruen pocket watch with a Unitas 285 movement, Gruen 497. It's very similar to the Unitas 6487 but has a date. The ratchet wheel screw won't unscrew. The movement is clean - no rust to speak of - so I know that can't be the culprit. I have used a lot of force and no progress. I assume this is a regular right-handed screw unlike the crown wheel which is left-handed. Any chance this ratchet wheel screw is left-handed? Any other suggestions will be greatly appreciated - Thanks!

Unitas 285.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Dan, Proceed with the strip down, remove the train bridge, gears and canon pinion, barrel then comes out attached to it bridge, soak in coca cola for two days, unscrews easy  then.

One advantage of coca cola is it lets total submersion and cheap. How else penetrants may get to arbour and the thread of ratchet screw? 

Do not drop the movement in coke yet.

Regards

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the suggestion. When I have just the bridge with barrel attached, should I remove the mainspring, or soak with it inside the barrel? If I try to remove the mainspring before the soak, I'm thinking it may be a little tricky to detach it from the arbor, though I'd feel better not soaking the mainspring in coca cola. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Dan-do looks like a nice clean movement. did you try to give it a nudge clockwise to feel any resistance or tightening? don't force it. I've not seen a left handed ratchet screw but you never know.  do you have any kind of penetrant laying around and oilers? maybe some lighter fluid? once you get the bridge with barrel assy. out, I would apply penetrant around the screw head, then turn it over and apply more at the barrel arbor, and a few more dabs to the holes(if any) thru the barrel cap and let it sit. better if over night, checking on it once in awhile. if that doesn't work, I might let it soak in lighter fluid(naptha) for an extended period. overnight is best, checking on it, seeing if it frees up. if all that fails, give the thing a short rinse in iso alcohol to dry it completely. at this point, you might have to add a little heat such as a jewelers lamp if you have one, or a cig lighter. apply the heat SPARINGLY, with the flame about 1/2 to 3/4 inch from the screw, using a circular motion. in other words, don't hold the flame in one place, keep it moving. you don't want to overheat the thing and run the risk of burning fingers. also, make sure your screwdriver width is as close to the width of the screw slot as possible so as not to slip, gouge, scratch or damage the slot or anything else and don't force anything. 

no expert here-just a couple things that have worked for me. try these and get back to us. good luck.

Mike

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mike,

Thanks - I'll give the penetrant a try. I was also thinking of running the bridge and its attached barrel assembly through the ultrasonic using the extra fine watch cleaner and cleaner rinse to see if that loosens it up. I'm thinking this can't hurt, though my one worry is, what if the micro-shaking of the ultrasonic loosens the barrel arbor cap and the mainspring then goes flying?

This stuck screw is such a surprise given the condition of the movement (no corrosion). Could be the last person to work on it just bared down too hard when tightening it.

Dan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, DanB said:

Hi Mike,

Thanks - I'll give the penetrant a try. I was also thinking of running the bridge and its attached barrel assembly through the ultrasonic using the extra fine watch cleaner and cleaner rinse to see if that loosens it up. I'm thinking this can't hurt, though my one worry is, what if the micro-shaking of the ultrasonic loosens the barrel arbor cap and the mainspring then goes flying?

This stuck screw is such a surprise given the condition of the movement (no corrosion). Could be the last person to work on it just bared down too hard when tightening it.

Dan

hey, 400 lb gorillas are more common than you think! yes, the ultrasonic gig you speak of is fine and might work even better. the chance, I believe, of the assy. trying to escape and go flying, are slim to none. with that cantankerous screw especially. even if it did, you won't lose it. just make sure to watch your eyeballs for flying objects! what size is the movement? also I should let you know that when I use my ultrasonic to clean parts, the solution I use is, yep you guessed it, naptha. parts into screen containers, screen containers into jars with naptha, then parts, containers, naptha and jars into machine filled with demineralized water half full and let er buck. so, I think you're right  on the money. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, MechanicMike said:

hey, 400 lb gorillas are more common than you think! yes, the ultrasonic gig you speak of is fine and might work even better. the chance, I believe, of the assy. trying to escape and go flying, are slim to none. with that cantankerous screw especially. even if it did, you won't lose it. just make sure to watch your eyeballs for flying objects! what size is the movement? also I should let you know that when I use my ultrasonic to clean parts, the solution I use is, yep you guessed it, naptha. parts into screen containers, screen containers into jars with naptha, then parts, containers, naptha and jars into machine filled with demineralized water half full and let er buck. so, I think you're right  on the money. 

all that being said, we shouldn't forget that this hang-up might not be seized screw at all but something more mechanical in nature such as seized or cross-threaded threads, somehow jammed up mainspring, or the whole dang train is jammed up with broken teeth or broken leafs on a pinion gear or worse. so exercise caution, make periodic checks and close inspections of the things, see if the elusive misfit reveals  itself.  I love beating an "overconfident gremlin." keep us posted...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's a 16.5 ligne/36.6mm movement. It really is almost identical to the ETA/Unitas 6497 except the motion works are at 12:00 since it's a pocket watch. I didn't think that the ratchet screw could be cross-threaded which would really make it stick if it is, but based on how flush it's lying to the ratchet wheel, that may not be the case. 

The good news is I have a spare parts 6497 movement to call upon in case anything gets really botched up related to the barrel and arbor, so there's not much to lose by trying different techniques. Plus the watch was passed on to me by a friend who knew of my recent interest in this stuff (so nice when that happens) so it's not an heirloom or anything extremely valuable.

Thanks again for weighing in.

Dan

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, DanB said:

Thanks for the suggestion. When I have just the bridge with barrel attached, should I remove the mainspring, or soak with it inside the barrel? If I try to remove the mainspring before the soak, I'm thinking it may be a little tricky to detach it from the arbor, though I'd feel better not soaking the mainspring in coca cola. 

 

Two days soak in coca cola wont hurt any metal, the suger in coke, however, may crystalize which is a pain to clean if inside the jewel hole. Personaly exclude hairspring and jewels and soak the rest.

The concern with removing the barrel and mainspring(MS) when still attached to the bridge is MS jumps out violently as you try removing the barrel and leave the arbour and lid still attached and spindle may break. If you plan re-using the MS, you would need to clean it anyway, which if manually I recommend with a brush and not cloth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, MechanicMike said:

Hi Dan-do looks like a nice clean movement. did you try to give it a nudge clockwise to feel any resistance or tightening? don't force it. I've not seen a left handed ratchet screw but you never know.  do you have any kind of penetrant laying around and oilers? maybe some lighter fluid? once you get the bridge with barrel assy. out, I would apply penetrant around the screw head, then turn it over and apply more at the barrel arbor, and a few more dabs to the holes(if any) thru the barrel cap and let it sit. better if over night, checking on it once in awhile. if that doesn't work, I might let it soak in lighter fluid(naptha) for an extended period. overnight is best, checking on it, seeing if it frees up. if all that fails, give the thing a short rinse in iso alcohol to dry it completely. at this point, you might have to add a little heat such as a jewelers lamp if you have one, or a cig lighter. apply the heat SPARINGLY, with the flame about 1/2 to 3/4 inch from the screw, using a circular motion. in other words, don't hold the flame in one place, keep it moving. you don't want to overheat the thing and run the risk of burning fingers. also, make sure your screwdriver width is as close to the width of the screw slot as possible so as not to slip, gouge, scratch or damage the slot or anything else and don't force anything. 

no expert here-just a couple things that have worked for me. try these and get back to us. good luck.

Mike

No heat specially flame, unless you discard the heated part. I do use heat( soldering gun)  on stuck broken screw thread since I don't collect broken screws.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm wondering that too.  Physics being what it is, if the crown wheel screw was left-handed, then the ratchet gear screw couldn't be.  But!...if the crown wheel screw was standard, wouldn't the ratchet gear have to be the one to be left-handed? 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, KarlvonKoln said:

I'm wondering that too.  Physics being what it is, if the crown wheel screw was left-handed, then the ratchet gear screw couldn't be.  But!...if the crown wheel screw was standard, wouldn't the ratchet gear have to be the one to be left-handed? 

No. The crown wheel screw may be be left threaded because the crown wheel, which turns counter clockwise under it, may tend to undo it. But the ratchet wheel screw does not move related to the ratchet wheel and barrel arbor airbor, no need for it being special, no matter which direction it turns.

That being said, if left threaded  the manufacturer gains commonality of two machining steps, and of two parts if it's identical to the crown wheel screw. To the cost of confusing most repairers as happened here,  and the risk of an unpleasant breakage. At least, both of them should have three slots not one.

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi all,

Mystery solved - the ratchet wheel screw is left handed. Wow. I briefly thought that could be the case, but still being new to this (just under a year with the tweezers) I assumed that most if not all crown wheel screws are left handed, ratchet wheels are right. Oh well, lesson learned. I looked for technical info on the movement on the AWCI site but could only find parts info. I should have checked the Ranftt page sooner (thanks Klassiker for that reminder).  

So the screw is out now, no damage done. 

Thanks again to all.

Dan

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, DanB said:

Hi all,

Mystery solved - the ratchet wheel screw is left handed. Wow. I briefly thought that could be the case, but still being new to this (just under a year with the tweezers) I assumed that most if not all crown wheel screws are left handed, ratchet wheels are right. Oh well, lesson learned. I looked for technical info on the movement on the AWCI site but could only find parts info. I should have checked the Ranftt page sooner (thanks Klassiker for that reminder).  

So the screw is out now, no damage done. 

Thanks again to all.

Dan

Good thing you posted this thread,  saved the watch and can drink the coca cola too, don't forget the pop corn.:lol:

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, DanB said:

Hi all,

Mystery solved - the ratchet wheel screw is left handed. Wow. I briefly thought that could be the case, but still being new to this (just under a year with the tweezers) I assumed that most if not all crown wheel screws are left handed, ratchet wheels are right. Oh well, lesson learned. I looked for technical info on the movement on the AWCI site but could only find parts info. I should have checked the Ranftt page sooner (thanks Klassiker for that reminder).  

So the screw is out now, no damage done. 

Thanks again to all.

Dan

left handed threads for the win!:Bravo: how did you get it? did you nudge the screw clockwise and it began to move? good stuff for future reference. 

Edited by MechanicMike
wrong word :)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, I nudged it to the right and it didn't take much for it to loosen. I had applied Marvel penetrating oil to the screw and let it sit overnight so that might have helped. At the outset when I didn't know it was left handed, I did give it a little nudge to the right but it didn't move and I didn't want to make matters worse if I nudged too hard. 

I did buy a can of coke just in case and now I can enjoy it with some popcorn!

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This is a very sad day for the industry.. For most of us being amateurs the cost of replacing parts for ETA,s etc will be beyond affordability for the customers.   see full statement below   We have now received the decision from Judge Michael Green on whether or not the High Court has jurisdiction to hear our claim against Swatch, and sadly it is not the decision we had hoped for.   As we have pointed out in previous news items (see below),the rules that Judge Green had to apply strictly prevented him from examining in any way how the Swiss Court arrived at its verdict, even if it is blatantly obvious that the verdict is wrong.   As Swatch’s lawyer was summing up in the last few minutes oft he hearing, the Judge twice pinned him asking if it was alright if, as a result of the Swiss verdict, consumers had to pay 50% more for their watch repairs. After some stumbling, their lawyer’s reply was “Yes”, so  I am quite sure that Judge Green left his court fully aware that the Swiss verdict does not reflect the norms of British Competition Law. However, the rules simply do not allow him to take that simple fact into account.   Judge Green noted that our two arguments relating firstly to British Competition Law now being different from that of the EU, and secondly to the contention that the legality of the Authorised Service Networks has not been tested, had both been mentioned in the Swiss verdict. Because they had been mentioned, he felt that to allow us to argue them again would constitute re examining the Swiss case, and could not be allowed.   As to our claim that we were denied our right to be heard because our evidence was not considered, our lawyers had argued that the evidence we provided could not have been looked at because had the Swiss Court done so, it could not have reached the conclusion that it did. In his verdict, Judge Green highlighted general statements in the Swiss verdict that evidence had been looked at, and acknowledged the arguments we made to him, but again he considered that this was re-examining the Swiss verdict, and could not be permitted.   Our case has attracted considerable interest within the Legal community, and within minutes of the decision being made public we were approached for comment by one of the largest subscription news services, Global Competition Review. They asked us two very pertinent questions, and I reproduce them for you below along with our responses, as they neatly summarise the consequences arising from our case.   What are the key takeaways?   Enormous damage has been done to the fundamentals of UK and European Competition Law by the Swiss courts. It has always been the case that the effect on consumers and competition has to be considered in any decision making, but we now have a ruling that states even monopolists can remove wholesale markets from the supply chain without any consumer benefit based justification. Those entities looking to subvert Competition Law and exploit consumers for their own benefit will be looking at this very carefully.   Has the court made the wrong decision? If so, will you appeal?   The issue lies not with the High Court, but rather with cross border jurisdiction treaties that have no requirement in them for foreign jurisdictions applying UK law to take account of the Ratio Legis [a legal term for the fundamental reasoning why the law was written] of that law, and have no remedy within them for UK Courts to overcome decisions that clearly do not.    After eight years of work, and a very considerable sum in legal costs, I can not begin to tell you how disappointed I am at this outcome. For the time being, there is no further route through the British Courts that Cousins can follow. However, I promised that we would fight to the end, and that promise stands.   The UK is no longer part of the Lugano Convention, whose rules Judge Green has applied, and as yet nothing permanent has replaced it. The political tide turned against repair prevention by restricting supply of spare parts some time ago, and our efforts on behalf of the Watch Repair industry have resulted in high level contacts within several Government Departments. You can be sure that we will keep working to overcome this unjust situation that we now all find ourselves in.    I will keep you advised.   Kind regards   Anthony
    • Dell fancy a challenge🤣   https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/285785684626?itmmeta=01HT29WVJY21Q94C73GYHGBTFX&hash=item428a277a92:g:15YAAOSwNRVmBAUz&itmprp=enc%3AAQAJAAAA0DIe4QLQBW66rSyIMiyBuk8GY%2B86pQ%2BQnxGbcNq7egAGe5DIs9YMmiWJIbZtMSxwNJIiJxuojbq523IeUSBQ6pJEIQ0tfz2ChrBR03BksmKINyklg1IK4GAfAcYY9Hta9wVeSZSZN7ZCNAfZTgKs9c4%2BUIUZ3Qjc3QjUXDn2uPRo1FiYOEewMG5A26EXb%2BclBgrqtbOmM6P3bea%2F8ZImOAXNI1HtbmtMk84pIGoM6ISwaM1PKFuADtTFMccS5e3ZjndCbXYXHrW3CecsV0edw3M%3D|tkp%3ABk9SR8q588nQYw Darwin’s theory of evolution has not been proven to be absolutely.  😀 
    • A already know the size movement I have the problem is the dial a had purchased has a dimension 20.6mm wide a want to find a watch case that going to fit the dial perfectly 
    • Hi.  I would like to take issue here regarding battery driven , watches, clocks,etc. I will and do repair these clocks in fact I have sever al in my collection as well as the regular mechanical ones. I have one on my mantle piece over 60 years old tha belonged to my wife’s Aunt,  long gone Iam afraid and it has been cleaned etc and never missed a beat and is accurate. Every one has their preduices as regards Electrical /electronic Horology but I regard it as part of the progress time line of the art of Horology and to be treated as such. Like Darwin’s theory of evolution it evolved.  Two cavemen knocking rocks together and a shard broke off , looking at it he worked out if it was stuck on the end of a stick he would have a spear. Likewise his pal seeing what he was up to picked up a piece  and did the same, now that’s evolution. Some clockmaker decided to build a clock that ran with a battery and no spring to wind up and break, progress and both the mechanical and battery driven clocks evolved, the battery ones got better to the point that if it broke you changed the complete unit. Likewise watches did the same but both can be repaired by people who approach Horology with an open mind without preduice.  We all have our likes and dislikes bu I for one would never dismiss any technology because I don’t like it.   The mobile phone is a good example of modern technology at work as is the automotive industry. There buttons and switches in my car I don’t use because to me they are not nesessary but I still drive the car.
    • I haven't gone through all the reading of what it might be or not. The first thing I would do if nothing obvious stands out is replace the mainspring, you have to start at the source of the power. Nine times out of ten that is the problem.  
×
×
  • Create New...