Jump to content

Chinese Mainspring Winders


Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, jdm said:

Well, brass is a metal anyway, it can also be hardened (but not after machining) making very good tools. Also, don't count on what you see shining on Chinese products pictures is steel, because they specialize in mystery metal which is given a good look by plating, etc. If the seller is a specialized one or claiming to be "factory official" there is some chance that asking gets you a sensed replay, but if it's a dropshipper they will always answer what you want to hear.

There's an article in May's Horological Journal about both the Bergeon sets and the Chinese versions. Basically, both get criticised - the Chinese sets for having brass arbors made to look like steel and the Bergeon set for having duplicate arbors and too little variation in the width of the winders. 

Mark Lovick got a mention on the video he made testing the Chinese sets. 

They did highly rate Rolex winders but obviously they're well out of most amateurs' price range so June's edition has an article on how to improve the Bergeon set to be more like the Rolex winders... might be worth a try if you have a lathe and know how to use it?! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, jdm said:

Take good measurements, add pictures, post all here and I'll see what I can do. 

Not my work, it's in the BHI's Horological Journal June 2021 an article by Justin Koullapis.  I can't scan copyright material then put it online, and I'm not sure I can translate the info into something usable either. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, Plato said:

I can't scan copyright material then put it online, and I'm not sure I can translate the info into something usable either. 

Never mind. Although I like to make parts on the lathe it's not like replacing a working brass arbor is a pressing matter, I think.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, jdm said:

Never mind. Although I like to make parts on the lathe it's not like replacing a working brass arbor is a pressing matter, I think.

The June article is about upgrading the Bergeon winders to work like the Rolex winders, not to fix the Chinese ones. IMG_20210706_205713.thumb.jpg.8326274089323a7d386b6d77c81d0ccf.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Its 4 o'clock in the morning here in the Uk, i cant sleep, i dont sleep, not much ever really. My brain never shuts off to rest, I'm just a constant thinker, i have to be very tired to be able to sleep,  i guess eventually it will be my undoing and my health will suffer because of it I'm sure. But while I'm here i want to get as much out of life as i can, and give as much as i can, to help,maybe to make a difference to someone's life if that is within my capability,recent events have made that need even more clear to me. I'm not sure where I'm going with this or why i bring it up , or if its relevant to want i want to talk about its just in my head right now. What i do want to talk about is something thats been on my mind for ages. I like to be prepared,  I'm not fond of surprises because surprises take control away and i am a bit of a control freak at times. This forum, Our Forum if i can call it that, is here because of two reasons. The guy that created it and keeps it funded and the people that joined it.  Without either, it would not exist, and lets face it one day it won't ( I'm a realist and i talk about things others dont or who are afraid to in other words folk that dont particularly prepare for the inevitable). How many of us visit here regularly ?  How many among us almost depend on the forum as a way of socialising because they are stuck at home and how many of us has it become part of a daily routine to check in and see if they can offer advice or get help with something they are working on or just to have a chat and engage in some banter. The members here are in the thousands and thousands have disappeared over the years many had just a fleeting visit. But there are a good few of us that know each other quite well and visit regularly. I dont know about you but i wouldnt want to lose that communication with you all, in all honesty it has become an important part of that side of my life and helps to feed my passion for all things watches. Some of you may think differently and thats ok, some of may stop and think # what would i do " Without Our Forum " # 
    • Naptha appears to be a general name and its content can be varied depending upon what it's specific use is. Lighter fluid as an example can be light or heavier also with other ingredients to help it burn. Try sesrching for benzine ( as opposed to benzene which is linked to causing health issues ) . There are other fluids such as ethanol that you could try and also methylated sprirts, mostly ethanol with a small percentage of methanol added. Experiment with any new chemical to see how quickly schellac dissolves in its presence. I have tried a few things but hexane is not one of them, i understand it does evaporate very quickly.  Be sure sure to check out any safety data on chemicals you try. Toxicity of fumes and flash point information, ultrasonic machines can heat up fluids even without a heater function. And of course always ask here for personal opinions when trying a new substance. 
    • I have that set and really like it. I prefer that crystal holder over the one that came with my Bergeon claw tool and any time I use the claw I use this one instead of the Bergeon one, just an additional bonus with this tool.
    • Is the Roamer not a split stem? I'm confused on your how your case is put together. If it is a front loader where is it you are putting the case screws? I love me some Roamer, do you have any photos?
    • Oh nice. I have a similar wedge style stump for my staking tool, so I'll give that a shot. Thanks!
×
×
  • Create New...