Jump to content

Easy out for watch screws?


PaulnKC

Recommended Posts

All,

I recently acquired a beautiful 1954 Omega with a near-mint 266 movement.

321645587_s-l1600(7).thumb.jpg.bfcf7d9200dbed07ac2fa6d807cb5263.jpg

I am thrilled with the condition of this watch.

However, there is one fault that I'd like to take care of if I can.

You can't tell in this picture, but one of the movement screws is broken with about half of the screw stuck in the base plate.

Is there anything like an easy-out for watch-size screws? Or some other method for removing a broken screw? I don't want to risk damaging the plate as it is in otherwise near-perfect condition. And the broken movement screw still has enough threads to function.

BUT - if there is a safe way to extract the broken part, I would like to do.

I can post some pics of the screw and plate (if that would help), but I would have to post those later, as I don't have them with me.

Many thanks,

-Paul

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it stuck solid, then it could be cross threaded. If not with some gentle persuasion with a correctly fitting screwdriver it should undo. Looking at all of the screws they are bruised so it has been serviced before with poorly fitting screwdriver head. I now use T shaped tipped screwdrivers using a Horotec sharpener. Although expensive less chance of slips and scratches. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, clockboy said:

Is it stuck solid, then it could be cross threaded. If not with some gentle persuasion with a correctly fitting screwdriver it should undo. Looking at all of the screws they are bruised so it has been serviced before with poorly fitting screwdriver head. I now use T shaped tipped screwdrivers using a Horotec sharpener. Although expensive less chance of slips and scratches. 

clockboy,

Yes - you are correct about the service and screw heads.

But both movement screws come out without trouble. It's just that one  is broken in half with the broken off part sitting in the base plate.

So, it's functional as-is, but ideally, I'd like to remove the broken part and get a new (unbroken) movement screw.

My question is about removing the broken off bit still in the base plate. For larger mechanical assemblies there is something called an easy-out that can be used for this task. I don't know if they make them small enough for watch movement screws. I doubt it.

-P.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, clockboy said:

Sorry I don't understand is the picture you have posted show the broken screw. For removing broken screws I have used this on a few occasions. 

clockboy,

That's my bad - I did mention in my original post (in the last sentence) that I could post more relevant photos, but would have to be later.

I will post a pic this evening that will show the situation directly.

But the tool you are showing looks like it has lots of potential!

Since you have used the tool - maybe you could have a look at the pic I post later and let me know what you think.

Many thanks!

-Paul 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's a lot of pics of that Chinese one, not one of which shows the tools radially aligned any closer than maybe 1mm... and they are all drills, the Bergeon has sort of round "claws" to grab into the screw and help it turn. Maybe with some re-work it could be OK...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, nickelsilver said:

There's a lot of pics of that Chinese one, not one of which shows the tools radially aligned any closer than maybe 1mm... and they are all drills, the Bergeon has sort of round "claws" to grab into the screw and help it turn. Maybe with some re-work it could be OK...

Yeah,

I also noticed.

I try to buy quality tools whenever possible. I have never been disappointed with Bergeon or Horotec (which is most of my tools).

-Paul 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, clockboy said:

Sorry I don't understand is the picture you have posted show the broken screw. For removing broken screws I have used this on a few occasions.

Here is a better pic - still not awesome, but you can see the tip of the broken screw coming through the base plate at about 9:00 (based on the photo orientation - not the orientation of the plate; i.e. the far left). It's a little tough to recognize because the silver screw looks similar to viewing the movement holder threw a screw hole.PA261980.thumb.jpg.0a893f2aae5ce3d79954293dbca6750a.jpg

In any event, I have ordered the Bergeon tool - and have high hopes that will do the trick.

 

Now - the next question - where to find an appropriate replacement screw?

Thanks to all who commented.

-Paul

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Nucejoe said:

Will you keep us posted with how useful the bergeon tool turns out.

Has the other end of the screws come out of the hole, I use nail clipper grasp it end.

 

 

Will do.

And good idea on the nail clippers.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

An easy and cheap way to remove broken screws is to use alum powder.

You have to remove all steel parts from the plate with the broken screw and you let it sit in alum powder mixed with water. You have to check it regulary but in about 24h, the steel from the screw will become soft and you will be able to poke it off with a toothpick and clean it very easily. I used this method once for a 1966 Omega watch and got perfect results.

Of course, you shouldn't use it on a movement with steel parts still on it as it will dissolve them but plates made of brass will not be affected by this product.

Here is the one I used and purchased at a local grocery store: https://www.helloflavour.ca/en-ca/our-brands/club-house/products/herbs-and-spices/spices/alum-powdered

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, thierry said:

An easy and cheap way to remove broken screws is to use alum powder.

You have to remove all steel parts from the plate with the broken screw and you let it sit in alum powder mixed with water. You have to check it regulary but in about 24h, the steel from the screw will become soft and you will be able to poke it off with a toothpick and clean it very easily. I used this method once for a 1966 Omega watch and got perfect results.

Of course, you shouldn't use it on a movement with steel parts still on it as it will dissolve them but plates made of brass will not be affected by this product.

Here is the one I used and purchased at a local grocery store: https://www.helloflavour.ca/en-ca/our-brands/club-house/products/herbs-and-spices/spices/alum-powdered

thierry,

Very cool! and thanks for posting.

It never hurts to have options.

-Paul

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have tried the Alum method with some success but it is slow. I must say the Chinese tool Paul shows looks impressive and a nice price. One method I did use was to use a series of micro drills into the broken screw then un-screwed with a small screwdriver.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a major screw issue and had to put the movement in my Lathe and drill out the screw. If you need to know the technique to do this I shall provide it. I used the screw removal tool and it did not work for my situation. Screw was locked in way too tight and it was the screw for the mainspring arbor.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, thierry said:

You have to remove all steel parts from the plate with the broken screw and you let it sit in alum powder mixed with water.

What is to add, is that the water should be hot, at least initially. That accelerates the action of the solution.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, jdrichard said:

I had a major screw issue and had to put the movement in my Lathe and drill out the screw. If you need to know the technique to do this I shall provide it. I used the screw removal tool and it did not work for my situation. Screw was locked in way too tight and it was the screw for the mainspring arbor.

Thank you jdrichard.

I would be interested to know the technique - and I would also be interested to know about the lathe that you used.

I don't think I'm close to buying one of those at the moment - but maybe in the future.

I think for my current situation, if I can't remove it with the Bergeon extractor tool, then I may try the alum powder - or may just leave as-is for the time being. Since, as I say, the broken screw will screw in to the plate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 hours ago, Nucejoe said:

Will you keep us posted with how useful the bergeon tool turns out.

Has the other end of the screws come out of the hole, I use nail clipper grasp it end.

Yes - the tip is through the other side, but the way the plate is formed, the tip doesn't sick out where it can be grabbed. So, can't try the nail clipper method on this one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you jdrichard.
I would be interested to know the technique - and I would also be interested to know about the lathe that you used.
I don't think I'm close to buying one of those at the moment - but maybe in the future.
I think for my current situation, if I can't remove it with the Bergeon extractor tool, then I may try the alum powder - or may just leave as-is for the time being. Since, as I say, the broken screw will screw in to the plate.

fa0398a0e62bca3724bb817f4e14e986.jpgArbor with Broken screw.0b9b0c1f57dfab616779feed32a8637b.jpgAfter the screw has been drilled out5c8e06d9405a82d7c08e87609030736f.jpgMy Lathe with the tale stock drill bit.

The process is to put the movement in a three jaw plate holder. Then find center with a graver and create a cone with an absolute center. Then, using circuit board drill bits, find a size just smaller than the diameter of the broken screw. When you drill through , it will leave a hollow screw that will crack when pried slightly with the tip of a screw driver.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, jdrichard said:

...
The process is to put the movement in a three jaw plate holder. Then find center with a graver and create a cone with an absolute center. Then, using circuit board drill bits, find a size just smaller than the diameter of the broken screw. When you drill through , it will leave a hollow screw that will crack when pried slightly with the tip of a screw driver...

jdrichard,

Very cool - thanks for posting. And nice macro photography. :)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Similar Content

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • See, what has happen is a normal consequece of the reducing the hammer size and changing it's shape by the removing metal from it. But here the hammer is adjustable and just adjustment is needed to correct, and this is what You have done. There is a rule for the adjustment and it is that the hammer must lay firmly on the seconds counter heart and there should be a litle free play in the same time of the minutes counter heart/hammer which alows counter movement of about 0.5 min on the small dial hand (+/- 0.25). Of course, there is no way to make one hammer to delay from the other, as they are one single part. What has changed too is the slope of the hammer head and thus the orientation of the heart has changed, and thus the switching finger position. This led to need of the finger position correction. The rule here is that switching of the minute counter has to start when the seconds counter hand is on '59'. Of course, the seconds hand must be positioned as so the resetting is at '0' exactly. If switching is earlier than 59, there will be no problem, but it will be wrong as reading can be not correct. If the switching starts later, the problems that You described can happen.
    • Thanks, This watch was in a box of old scrape units that a friend gave me. They used to be his late father's who was a watchmaker before the war and then continued later in life. I picked this one out as it looked like it had potential, and I liked the dial, it's been a bit of a learning curve for a beginner but I was determined to get it going. Now I'm on the final lap it feels good. I'm just wondering whether to invest in a decent set of hand placement tools or stick with the cheap Chinese red thing I have, decisions decision 😆
    • An update, for everyone who contributed advice, and for those who come after with a similar problem. Based on the answers received, I decided to work on the face of the hammer first. I used a square degussit stone to guarantee a vertical surface to work against, and ground the face back until it was square across 90% of the depth. I was conscious of the risk of removing too much material.* After I'd got the shape how I wanted it, I polished the surface with lapping film. To cut a long story short, it did the trick and the hammer hasn't slipped off the cam since. Of course, that wasn't the end of my problems. Have a look at this video and tell me what you think is wrong. https://youtu.be/sgAUMIPaw98 The first four attempts show (0 to 34 sec.) the chrono seconds hand jumping forwards, the next two attempts (35 to 47 sec.) seem "normal", then on the seventh attempt (48 to 54 sec.) the seconds hand jumps to 5 sec. and the minute counter jumps to 1. The rest of the video just shows repeats of these three variants. I solved it by rotating the minute counter finger on the chronograph (seconds) runner relative to the cam.  I'd be interested to hear your opinions on that. It seemed to be the right thing to do, but maybe I've introduced another problem I'm not aware of. * What is the correct relationship between the two hammers and cams, by the way? Should both hammers strike the cams exactly at the same time, or is it correct for the minute counter hammer to be a bit behind the seconds hammer? In this picture, I removed the adjusting screw at 1, and the hammers are contacting the cams simultaneously at 3 and 4. I had to turn the screw down tight to achieve this condition after stoning the seconds hammer and replacing the bridge.
    • It was easy enough to pop off. Once I had the cannon pinion hanging on the blades of the stump, I got my #2 tweezers on the gear attached to the staff and levered it down. That way none of the force was on the brass wheel itself.   I reinstalled it and the bridge, and it looks like a small but reasonable amount of end shake. It also spins easily with a blower. It stops quickly, but I think that's due to the large shoulder and about what I'd expect from this wheel.  
    • Oh, right. For some reason I was picturing a monocoque case in my head. Good looking watch!
×
×
  • Create New...