Jump to content

Amplitude drops or watch stops with crown screwed down


AP1875

Recommended Posts

I serviced a Chinese movement, has good results on the timegrapher. 

Installed it in the watch case and when I screw the crown down the amplitude drops off dramatically to 170-200. 

I assume this is due to the stem? However I'm not sure how the stem can affect amplitude and cause the watch to stop? 

Time grapher results without crown screwed down. 20190917_224559.thumb.jpg.5795cd5ad9aff1c1214b71b7ec607ac2.jpg20190917_224644.thumb.jpg.cc2f8dc80d4434157503212c10911076.jpg20190917_224620.thumb.jpg.7d9ad2354b3a2a91cc0efb363d23e936.jpg

 

Edited by AP1875
Spelling
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Could it simply be pushing the movement against the movement ring, and thus fouling the balance, or some other part?

Alternatively it may cause the movement, or one of the hands to press hard against the face, or push the movement up so that the second hand touches the crystal.

A few pictures might help us decide on the cause.

Edited by AndyHull
Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, AndyHull said:

Could it simply be pushing the movement against the movement ring, and thus fouling the balance, or some other part?

Alternatively it may cause the movement, or one of the hands to press hard against the face, or push the movement up so that the second hand touches the crystal.

A few pictures might help us decide on the cause.

Thanks for your reply, 

There's no movement ring, so that's ruled out. 

I can remove the glass and see if it has the same problem ruling the hands out but the movement is held by clamps so I don't think it's anything I can see. Which is why I wanted to question the stem causing the issue inside the movement. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Given that the quality control of some of these Chinese movements is marginal at best, and woeful at worst, it may well be the case that pressure against the stem is causing it to jam somehow. Exactly how is the question. The stem itself may be too long, or machined out of spec., or the tolerances of the case or the screw in crown may be wrong, or the stem may be too short, and screwing it in, may cause it to pull out slightly, jamming up the keyless work.

If you manually push the stem in with the movement uncased, do you get the same effect?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, I removed the movement again and reinstalled it. I ran it without the case clamps tightened down that was fine so tightened them slightly. Seems fine upto now. 

So it must've been something inside the keyless/stem? 

How does a keyless/stem affect amplitude? I can't visualise what's happening inside the movement. 

I'm not familiar with the term castle wheel, are you referring to the winding or sliding pinion? 

49 minutes ago, watchweasol said:

Hi  I think Andy is on right track regarding tolerences, When assembled and tested the movements would not be cased so a problem of this nature wouldn't show up untill cased,    My guess would be an over length stem pressing on the castle wheel and interfering with the movement .

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"Castle wheel" is probably another term for the sliding pinion since it looks like a little castle turret.

 

 slidingpinion.jpg

 

If the case alignment with a screw-down crown isn't perfect between the stem and the movement, the stem can act like a spring when the crown is tightened and exert a force on the movement in an up or down direction. If that makes any part of the movement touch a part it's not supposed to (fouling), it can have a tremendous effect on the performance, including amplitude.  

 

You may never be able to find out exactly what's touching what because as soon as you release the stem, the pressure goes away. You might be able to put it all together and let it run for a month or so and then take the movement apart and look for wear marks on the pieces, but I wouldn't recommend that. It's better just to use a spacer to make sure the the case, dial, movment and stem are all in alignment.

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

8 minutes ago, eccentric59 said:

You may never be able to find out exactly what's touching what because as soon as you release the stem, the pressure goes away.

With ingenuity you could be able to. Plastigauge was invented for that. Now, I've never heard of it being uses on watches, but one could use aluminium foil stacked in different places to find where and how much shimming is needed.
Philippe Dufour once saidn that case makers "are not very precise people", maybe the OP found himself in the same predicament :)

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, AP1875 said:

The watch seems fine now. Just so I know for the future if it was the length of the stem what is the most practical way of shortening it? 

I'm also interested in knowing how to cut a stem, because I have a project that will involve to adjust the length of the new stem I bought. I think the final fine tune is done with a small grain file, but I don't know what tool to use for the first "big" cuts (I'll have to buy that tool, I don't think I have anything for that).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm also interested in knowing how to cut a stem, because I have a project that will involve to adjust the length of the new stem I bought. I think the final fine tune is done with a small grain file, but I don't know what tool to use for the first "big" cuts (I'll have to buy that tool, I don't think I have anything for that).

Any hand held wrench cutter will do. The file the end to a dome.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, watchweasol said:

shortening a stem is not rocket science but needs great care not to over do it. 

Stem cut a bit too short? No problem, drop a minuscule piece of wire in the crown, apply locking agent and screw down well. Shhh don't tell anyone! 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, jdm said:

Stem cut a bit too short? No problem, drop a minuscule piece of wire in the crown, apply locking agent and screw down well. Shhh don't tell anyone! 

You will get away with about two thread turns of missing depth that way (allegedly.. not that I would know of course) any more than that and you might have to resort to a stem extender or a new stem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, AndyHull said:

You will get away with about two thread turns of missing depth that way (allegedly.. not that I would know of course) any more than that and you might have to resort to a stem extender or a new stem.

That's why a wrote "a bit". Anyway, a 1.0mm stem can have a 0.2 or 0.25 pitch, which means a crown tapped 3mm deep takes like 15 or 20 turns to full screw. One can have undercut 2mm and still have enough threads to hold safe.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's why a wrote "a bit". Anyway, a 1.0mm stem can have a 0.2 or 0.25 pitch, which means a crown tapped 3mm deep takes like 15 or 20 turns to full screw. One can have undercut 2mm and still have enough threads to hold safe.

Too much math. I would just make another stem on a lathe

Sent from my GT-N5110 using Tapatalk

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This seems to be complicated case... We have many variables here and we need to exclude some of them to make some progress. We have plots that show amplitude variations, but we don't know if this variations are significant, as they can be 'amplified' or 'smoothed' by the software. So, some observation of the amplitude by eye will be of help. Then, if we really have not isochronical work, then the main reason for this would be the hairspring being not 'linear'. And not linear may be sometimes not only because 'touching', but because bad hairsping material structure. Some of the advanced watchmakers claim that repairing badly bent hairspring is useless, because this springs will never be isochronic again.  Well, my own observations are that such thing happens, but not in all the cases and it depends on the case if the result is acceptable or not. I will not suppose here that this spring has been repaired, but it has some strange behavior watching at it's work. It will be good if it is possible to test the movement with another balance or thest the balance on another movement...
    • The more common Jewel hole diameters are from about 0.07mm to 0.50mm. Those are the sizes in the Seitz jewel gauge tool.
    • Hello and welcome from Leeds, England. 
    • OK, several things to say here. The thought thay if with the old spring the movement works 16 hours, then replacing the spring will solve that - is totally wrong. With a new spring the movement probably will work for 17 hours. The power reserve is practically not reduced when the spring gets weak with the age. It is rather something wrong with the movement. As You worked on the hairspring, we need to  confirm that it is OK now before everything else. So, thake the lever out and do the free oscillations test. What is the result? I expect numbers, not only 'it is good' or 'it is not good'. Then, this is no jewels pin lever movement, so this is not unusual to have not well regulated or even worn escapement, this is the main reason that this kind of watches doesn't work as long and reliable as the jeweled escapement ones. You can find many of them with no wear at the crown and case, and this is because they stopped working normally pritty soon after purchase.
    • Welcome 🙂 Inherited watches are very tricky. Some of them, or all, do have sentimental value, perhaps not to you but perhaps to others in the family. Ruining them doesn't make you popular. Start on innocent watches who do no harm, not to your wallet nor to others 😉 BTW; for in the future it would be helpful to others to mention your location in your profile. Success 🤗  
×
×
  • Create New...