Jump to content

Question, HS in the family


Recommended Posts

Question, Dr ranfft lists the entire family of each caliber. I wonder if the HS fitted on each member is of the same springness,width, thickness?    That is;  Providing the same beat and enough spring length, can the HS off of one be flown with the wheel of another member? 

Thanks in advance.          Joe

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, rogart63 said:

If the movement is different Hz i think they can have different HS . Been there with a  AS 1746. They come in different HZ versions . Didn't work and at first i could figure out why.

Correct, my experience shows HS of different frquencies are not interchangable even if flown with the wheel,  by the time you reach the right beat, you are left with a funny looking HS due to too much cutting. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the past, like over 50 years ago, each spring was vibrated to its balance. Each balance, while superficially identical, could be different enough from the next one in the box to make the hairsprings incompatible. The modern method is more automatic, the springs are colleted then cut to a given length, the terminal curve formed, stud attached. They are then each tested and graded into about 20 categories; the balances are likewise graded into 20 categories. If you look at the results of the categorization, it makes a nice bell curve, with the majority falling within perhaps 4-5 middle spots, the rest dispersed in decreasing numbers towards the ends.

The balances and hairspring are just mated according to the category. If you try to mate a Cat 1 spring to a Cat 20 balance it won't work at all. If you try between Cat 9,10,11, it may work OK. Of course there's no way to know which one is which once it leaves the timing department of the factory.

 

Balances with screws add a dimension of adaptability as you can add and remove weight easily. Solid balances can only have weight removed, and the adjustment is permanent.

Edited by nickelsilver
  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, nickelsilver said:

Balances with screws add a dimension of adaptability as you can add and remove weight easily. Solid balances can only have weight removed, and the adjustment is permanent.

Agree and you also have balance washers as well that can be added for weight, they have to be added evenly, if not the balance will be out of true. 

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, vinn3 said:

  how do you remove weight accuratly from a "screwless balance"?   vin

With a very small drill on the underside of the rim. There are machines used in manufacturing that can very accurately determine the heavy spot and then very accurately remove material (the old machines used drill, the newer ones use a micro slitting saw). For the bench watchmaker how much to remove for poising is a matter of experience; the drill is usually held in a pinvice, and might be something like 0.20mm diameter.

Edited by nickelsilver
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you Gentleman. 

So, BW and HS on some vintage and I gather all antique time pieces, were to be (in pair ) vibrated to the design beat . Two BW on same assembly line were dynamically different even though they weighted and looked the same.

If a HS for a rare collectible pieces is needed, I think one can be extracted from other( not so collectibles) members of the family and true would then need to be vibrated with the BW anew.

I have been finding hairsprings in the family, that can be( cut) vibrated compatible with the BW at hand.

I hope to have made my question more clear to understand, which is , other than the length, are HS within a family the same?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Nucejoe said:

Thank you Gentleman. 

So, BW and HS on some vintage and I gather all antique time pieces, were to be (in pair ) vibrated to the design beat . Two BW on same assembly line were dynamically different even though they weighted and looked the same.

If a HS for a rare collectible pieces is needed, I think one can be extracted from other( not so collectibles) members of the family and true would then need to be vibrated with the BW anew.

I have been finding hairsprings in the family, that can be( cut) vibrated compatible with the BW at hand.

I hope to have made my question more clear to understand, which is , other than the length, are HS within a family the same?

 

If you mean the same CGS number (that is how they are classified), then yes, they should be the same.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, nickelsilver said:

If you mean the same CGS number (that is how they are classified), then yes, they should be the same.

I guess the name of  this metric system is adapted in horology, CGS;  Centemeter, Gram, Seconds.  Use of this term would have saved me a lot of strugling just to expalin a simple question. 

Best Regards.       and thank you for the time you put in.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/4/2019 at 5:37 PM, vinn3 said:

  how do you remove weight accuratly from a "screwless balance"?   vin

I guess you would have to depend on machines/ tools to remove the right amount of weight. Most basic tool should let you check for poise , easily.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/4/2019 at 1:18 PM, nickelsilver said:

In the past, like over 50 years ago, each spring was vibrated to its balance. Each balance, while superficially identical, could be different enough from the next one in the box to make the hairsprings incompatible. The modern method is more automatic, the springs are colleted then cut to a given length, the terminal curve formed, stud attached. They are then each tested and graded into about 20 categories; the balances are likewise graded into 20 categories. If you look at the results of the categorization, it makes a nice bell curve, with the majority falling within perhaps 4-5 middle spots, the rest dispersed in decreasing numbers towards the ends.

The balances and hairspring are just mated according to the category. If you try to mate a Cat 1 spring to a Cat 20 balance it won't work at all. If you try between Cat 9,10,11, it may work OK. Of course there's no way to know which one is which once it leaves the timing department of the factory.

 

Balances with screws add a dimension of adaptability as you can add and remove weight easily. Solid balances can only have weight removed, and the adjustment is permanent.

Vintage hairsprings is probably the largest headache since most of the old knowledge has been forgotten when the modern watchmaker begun to buy balance complete with already matched spings and balances. The balance on these are laser adjusted.
On the packages of the vintage springs there often are the markings Gr and Fce learning what they stand for would help people like me with less knowledge to choose the correct spring to vibrate faster. Was there any standardized system for this type of marking?

IMG_20190904_190416.jpg

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@HSL  are these colleted?   I read some producers graded their products in like 4 or 6 classes by strength, like Gr4  stronger than Gr3.  One just chose the right class and had to collet, vibrate, curve the end, stud.

A bigger headache are uncolleted hairsprings, an extra unknown.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...
On 9/4/2019 at 3:48 PM, nickelsilver said:

In the past, like over 50 years ago, each spring was vibrated to its balance. Each balance, while superficially identical, could be different enough from the next one in the box to make the hairsprings incompatible. The modern method is more automatic, the springs are colleted then cut to a given length, the terminal curve formed, stud attached. They are then each tested and graded into about 20 categories; the balances are likewise graded into 20 categories. If you look at the results of the categorization, it makes a nice bell curve, with the majority falling within perhaps 4-5 middle spots, the rest dispersed in decreasing numbers towards the ends.

The balances and hairspring are just mated according to the category. If you try to mate a Cat 1 spring to a Cat 20 balance it won't work at all. If you try between Cat 9,10,11, it may work OK. Of course there's no way to know which one is which once it leaves the timing department of the factory.

 

Balances with screws add a dimension of adaptability as you can add and remove weight easily. Solid balances can only have weight removed, and the adjustment is permanent.

Hi @nickelsilver  What is the name of the tool/instrument the colleted hairsprings are tested with?   I presume the coil strength is tested=measured to some degree of accuracy.

Happy Christmas .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nucejoe- I don't know a specific name other than vibrating tool. Back in the days watch companies might have gad their own proprietary tools, Greiner made industrial level vibrating tools too, but the bulk of sprung balances come out of Nivarox and they have their own stuff.

For the bench watchmaker the "Luthy" tool is the standard, using a master balance. A member here is making an electronic master balance to fit these tools at a very reasonable cost which I intend to try out as soon as I can get around to ordering one.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

Nucejoe- I don't know a specific name other than vibrating tool. Back in the days watch companies might have gad their own proprietary tools, Greiner made industrial level vibrating tools too, but the bulk of sprung balances come out of Nivarox and they have their own stuff.

For the bench watchmaker the "Luthy" tool is the standard, using a master balance. A member here is making an electronic master balance to fit these tools at a very reasonable cost which I intend to try out as soon as I can get around to ordering one.

Thank you for taking the time to explain.   Best wishes.  Joe

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • 🤔 leaving the EU meant that UK was no longer part of the convention and have already been turned down an independent reapplication. I'm pretty sure courts have to be held in Switzerland in this case. There will be a lot more watches stashed away in draws  tbh, folk wont be able to afford to maintain them. Cheap watches will be bought and top end watches by folk with plenty of cash that can pay for service and repair. The expensive once in a lifetime gifts and everything else inbetween will be at the forgotton when they stop working. I know i was being a numpty, get used to it 😄
    • although not in this case.  It was the Lugano Convention and its deficiencies that allowed a Swiss court decision in the first place.  This isnt really a Brexit issue at all.  A decision that affects both the EU and the UK should never have been heard in Switzerland. I bet the authorised service centres in the UK are pretty pleased.  It's a massive shame, though; I believe watch owners should be able to choose to have their watch serviced by whoever they trust.
    • Hi guys I think that old hippy is correct, it opens the gates for china to manufacture aftermarket spare parts. considering that they already do work on behalf of the Swiss I guess this decision gives the a little more legitimacy to tool up and I am sure they will take advantage of the situation either with or without the blessing of the Swiss watch industry  Having read about the protectionist machinations of the Swiss in the history of Europe they were the only ones to get fat at everybody else’s expense. I think the outcome could have been guessed at but ,  fair play to Cousins UK for standing up to them.  Now the question,  will everybody boycott Swiss watches and Swatch, no way they will still fill their coffers.  Me I stick with the Japanese once renowned for cheap shitty watches who came good through industrial effort and don’t for get the Russians that most dismiss as low grade crap. Wouldn’t buy a swatch product ever how about you all.? a
    • Hold the crown when in winding position, move the click away from the crown wheel, and then while holding the crown let it slowly unwind. I recollect that you must remove the automatic device bridge first, but maybe I'm wrong. You can first try without removing the automatic device bridge.
×
×
  • Create New...