Jump to content

Star Lathe 61626, worth it?


JBerry

Recommended Posts

Hey guys,

Today I have an opportunity to pick up this lathe for a pretty reasonable price locally (€300).

I have no experience with a lathe and this could be my first.

From the pictures is there anything noteworthy missing or damaged?

Anything specific I should check when viewing it?

Thanks so much in advance!

1 Star Lathe.JPG

2 Star Lathe.JPG

3 Star Lathe.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looks complete. You will need a motor to run it. Check the lathe bed and make sure it is smooth with no marks in it. Ask what type of work has been undertaken. how old is it? Make sure the collets are in good shape and not strained, out of shape collets are no good.  A fair price I would say. 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, oldhippy said:

Looks complete. You will need a motor to run it. Check the lathe bed and make sure it is smooth with no marks in it. Ask what type of work has been undertaken. how old is it? Make sure the collets are in good shape and not strained, out of shape collets are no good.  A fair price I would say. 

Thanks very much OH! I'll be sure to ask how old it is before viewing, and check what you mentioned when I see it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

excessive clearance in the head stock (wobble) is the bigest problem in any lathe. if thats good -- go for it.  vin
Thanks Vin. Going to look at it in a couple of hours. Fingers crossed

Sent from my Redmi 4X using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

excessive clearance in the head stock (wobble) is the bigest problem in any lathe. if thats good -- go for it.  vin
If there is any wobble, is it possible to fit new bearings to the headstock?

Sent from my Redmi 4X using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If there is any wobble, is it possible to fit new bearings to the headstock?

Sent from my Redmi 4X using Tapatalk

These lathes use double tapered hardened steel sleeve bearings that interact directly with corresponding tapers on the spindle. They're theoretically replaceable but practically next to impossible. They can be re-lapped to a certain degree if necessary.

They are incredibly tough and long-lived, and require very excessive abuse over a long time to become noticeably worn. That lathe looks great, great price, and older is better overall when it comes to this type of machine.
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

These lathes use double tapered hardened steel sleeve bearings that interact directly with corresponding tapers on the spindle.

I agree with your remarks.  Offhand I can't think if a more difficult thing to make, to get a taper to mate is almost trivial in comparison to getting the two tapers perfectly mated, and with very fine finish they have to have.   There were lots of lathe makers so many figured it out; It would be great one day get a detailed account or discussion with someone who made these.  There are just a lot of head scratching challenges to machining, grind and lapping that geometry for a perfect fit..

The good news is for probably the 1 1/2 dozen or so I've had apart I've only once seen this form of bearing in poor condition (a Schaublin 70 let run without oil.  sad.  Its on the shelf until I figure out how to remake the bearings).  It was obvious turning it over by hand that there was a serious problem. 

These are hydrodynamic bearing and what happens is the shaft runs on a thin wedge of oil.  There should never be metal to metal contact so they should last forever in theory, which based on the number of 100+ year old ones I've seen, they do.  Good news indeed.  Let them run out of oil though....shame on you.  On that note, regarding care of them,  remove the tension on the belt when not in use and before use, after oiling, turn the spindle over by hand a few times to make sure there is oil all around the bearing.  Let it warm up at slow speeds for a bit (i usually ad oil at that point) rather than turning it on and going pedal to the metal

With bearings in good shape I think that is an excellent deal.  I just sold a Star like that.  It also had the 5 step collets and motor and sold for $1100 Cdn.  I believe that lathe is still offered about 10x that asking price

 

Edited by measuretwice
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the replies folks! I picked it up and it's in remarkable condition, no play at all or even marks on the lathe. Collets are in good shape too. It belonged to a now deceased watchmaker who worked for Girard-Perregaux and then taught at the Irish Swiss Institute of Horology where he first studied. Pretty sure he purchased it when he started studying, around the early 60s I think.
I also picked up a nice assortment of Gravers and two almost complete incabloc part assortments.

Also, does anyone have any idea what the part being held up in the photo is? 3399c154d5794aee56556fc9606ec607.jpg8f959769958d2f612615a1b000b7e712.jpgbcf17f64c73867cb1b0307cd6d9b232b.jpg73cc66d9822e4beb6d67ed4da62196a6.jpg

Sent from my Redmi 4X using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bergeon 30421 are escapement files

The two boxes are the complete Incabloc system pieces split up in there boxes they come with a chart which you use as a reference when it comes to replacing the parts. I know this because I had the identical boxes.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

These lathes use double tapered hardened steel sleeve bearings that interact directly with corresponding tapers on the spindle. They're theoretically replaceable but practically next to impossible. They can be re-lapped to a certain degree if necessary.

They are incredibly tough and long-lived, and require very excessive abuse over a long time to become noticeably worn. That lathe looks great, great price, and older is better overall when it comes to this type of machine.

    if it is from a Wet climate, may be rusty in side, that is hard to repair.  vin

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

    if it is from a Wet climate, may be rusty in side, that is hard to repair.  vin
If it somehow rusted inside the spindle to bearing area, where there is almost 99.99% chance of there being at least oil residue, while remaining pristine looking everywhere else, that'd be odd. But the contact area of these bearings is so massive relative to the actual size of the machine I'd be surprized that just cleaning off the rust wouldn't get it back in service true as can be.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the advice guys! One more question, anyone have a good beginners lathe book recommendation? Watchmaker's and model engineers lathe by Donald Lecarle seems popular and easy to source

Sent from my Redmi 4X using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't recall what's in there but DeCarle is normally a good source of info. Jendritzky's book is pretty good, I haven't seen it yet but Archie Perkins is a sort of lathe guru so I'd recommend his book without hesitation. I haven't seen any youtube videos that show actual good technique, most are pretty hackish. AWCI has some good videos from Ron DeCorte.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, JBerry said:

Watchmaker's and model engineers lathe by Donald Lecarle seems popular and easy to source

Its a bit of a disappointing book actually it's mainly just a list of old lathes from various manufacturers and their specifications, but doesn't explain much in the way of using a lathe any other De Carle book I would rate but not that one, there's is plenty on youtube to watch about watchmakers lathes.

Edited by wls1971
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its a bit of a disappointing book actually it's mainly just a list of old lathes from various manufacturers and their specifications, but doesn't explain much in the way of using a lathe any other De Carle book I would rate but not that one, there's is plenty on youtube to watch about watchmakers lathes.
That's a shame, thanks for the heads up though!

Sent from my Redmi 4X using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Star CNC/automatic lathes are Japanese. Slightly confusing as they make a "Swiss" type lathe, which is a type of lathe where the material moves back and forth within the headstock and the tools are stationary with regards to the axis of the work (they move radially).

Star watchmaking tools are made in the mountains next to Neuchatel.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On ‎1‎/‎19‎/‎2019 at 8:53 AM, measuretwice said:

Where did see that Star in Utah makes lathes or CNC?   The look like a foundry and jobbing machine shop.  Star watchmaker lathes and tools are from Switzerland.

   i have seen a lot of big lathes marked "star".    they would buy lathes,  rebuild and sell them - often to the same outfit they got it from.  the shop i was in also rebuilt lathes and milling machines.  maybe jewlers lathes,  maybe not.  the instrument shop used jewelers  lathes. so.  that is where i saw Star lathes.  vin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, nickelsilver said:

Star watchmaking tools are made in the mountains next to Neuchatel.

I've been to Neuchatel, such a beautiful part of the world.  One of my kids did a year of high school there.

Anyway, my question.  I gather Star lathes are still made, but boy, are they ever trying to keep it a secret!  Cousins list one package.  Tony's site says the manufacturer is " A. Gentil & Company of La Brevine, Switzerland".   I can't find anything with internet searches.  A bit academic as I don't have a Star now, but you'd think they'd make themselves known - how does one contact them for accessories, parts or a whole boxed lathe? 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • somewhere in the universe although as I'm answering this I remembered which discussion group. Somebody had a similar question loss basically expanded it to the watch would totally disintegrate in my think like 30 years. I'd have to go back and find the original discussion if I can the person seem to think that they hairspring would disintegrate like you describe and just metal on metal wearing out the entire watch. Except of course we all work on watches over 30 years and they obviously do not disintegrate. Plus somebody came along and explained why hairsprings do not have the same issues as mainsprings. Although hairsprings do end up with watchmakers insisting on bending and playing with them and torturing them etc. and that obviously is not good for the metal at all. one of the problems that you're having here it is what is the purpose of the test that started this discussion? Let me go and snip out the original image as you can see from images above this watch is horrible. Or is it? What is the purpose of the images up above in other words what exactly would use this test for? The real purpose this test is show the effect of amplitude on timekeeping. Or specifically you're looking for mechanical issues that are causing fluctuations in amplitude which unfortunately shows up  with timekeeping. or basically everything affects timekeeping but amplitude is affected by the mechanical characteristics of the watch from the mainspring to the balance wheel and unfortunately as it's a mechanical watch your always going to have power fluctuations. so how do we rule out unacceptable fluctuations versus the natural characteristic of the watch? Usually if you can find a repeating pattern you can narrow it down to the offending components for instance I'm attaching a PDF. on the second page of the PDF it talks about 21st-century equipment versus paper tape timing machines. Then they give an example of timing problems solely caused by a faulty component. although off you have a user's manual for a paper tape machine it does explain that you can find faulty components by looking at the variations on your paper tape seeing how often they repeat and do the same thing without the fancy software. Even though it was claimed that you couldn't do that in other words you couldn't find a pattern? One of the problems that comes up with modern LCD-based timing machines versus software is limited screen size. In other words it makes it very hard to look for patterns you'll see variations in numbers but it's hard to tell what's going on which is why the display above is really nice to see if there is a problem. for instance here's a paper printout from a witschi timing machine it does look distorted because I changed the speed at which the image would move across the screen. In other words I was trying to figure out a way to extend the screen to being much longer as I was looking for a pattern as you can see there doesn't appear to be a pattern at all so basically we end up with a watch that I cannot time at all they cannot really figure out what the problem is and I actually cannot find a pattern even begin the figure out where the problem might be. Plus I agreed to service this watch for free as I was going to use it for the purposes of a lecture. In other words it's a nice railroad grade pocket watch and I wanted to show before how horrible amplitude is and how wonderful it looks after serviced and after servicing it looked exactly the same still horrible. Then I used software for a clock timing machine and came up with this interesting image one a minor problems we have with time plots and  how they look is that they all do things a little bit differently. So this was occurring approximately every five minutes. Then we need another chart then I replaced something in the watch and we now get this one of the things that I was always bothered with was if I had put the hands on after servicing would the watch have Time? Because the pattern was repeating the watch would average that out may  it would have Time. Oh and what did I change somebody had swapped the mainspring barrel for something different were getting a binding between the mainspring in the center wheel pinion. so the problem you're having is what exactly is the problem? the purpose of the test image is to look for mechanical problems causing amplitude problems. Because it's a mechanical watch your always going to have variations so are the variations in this watch abnormal or normal for this watch? Once we eliminate the mechanical issues beyond it's a mechanical watch then you can work on timing issues. for timing issues I recommend going back to the normal display that were used to and make sure you have your averaging times set correctly. In other words while the graphical display is basically real time years of the numbers are averaged over time. Anywhere from 20 to 40 seconds depending upon whose specs you're looking at. So basically they will average out the problems were seeing on this time plot.   one of my amusements with students that go to the same school is that you have different instructors. So this gives you different experiences like what exactly is tight anyway as I don't remember any thing like this? Then did you know that Rolex at least in Geneva as I visited their service center replace all the screws in the watch every time they service the watch. then why did they do that because they use power screwdrivers and tighten those things down as tight as you can get them which has a problem. How many times can you tighten screw down really tight before the hints break off. So they replace the screws every single time. So personally I don't think they have to be so tight that you're in danger snapping head off that's too tight in my opinion. but the screws definitely shouldn't be falling out either which I've occasionally see and where people just don't tighten their screws tight enough.   Horologica Times -- May 2004 From the Workshop witschi time plot.pdf
    • I guess it is a possibility, but the train wheel bridge was pressed down all the way so I'm not so sure. Then again, the screws weren't tightened at all (imagine being screwed down all the way but using a piece of Rodico instead of a screwdriver). Anyway, the movement is now fully stripped so we'll have to see once I've assembled it again. BTW I found the post where @nickelsilver wrote about tightening screws: As he writes: "In school, if your screws aren't tight, like you think they might snap, you get your movement tossed in the sawdust box!" I'm really curious to know why it is so important to tighten the screws that hard. I usually stop when it feels like there is no chance the screw can start to unscrew itself. Also, screwing down that hard requires perfectly dressed and perfectly sized screwdrivers to avoid slippage and/or damaging the screw slot.
    • This place has them, cheaper than I saw on ebay and they appear to be a legitimate supplier: https://maddisonsofdurham.co.uk/watch-parts/capacitors/seiko-batteries-capacitors/seiko-capacitor-kinetic-30235mz-tc920s-5m42-5m22-5m23-battery-3023-5mz-3023-5my/?gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw7-SvBhB6EiwAwYdCASmviGb9G2ZGW3CtcUZBkNgglcgfPKoqnpOzrzruiPtm69f6DX7UGhoCKl4QAvD_BwE There is also a note at the bottom of the page about them being a newer type, with a slightly different part number.  
    • Are we ignoring  that another watch on tg showed similar rate fluctuation. Did I miss any conclusion made on this sigificant  point ?    Springs have high fatigue threshold,   meaning angle of  bend/distortion  has to be very sharp to cause material fatigue .  An evidence to this point is the bend we form at end of terminal curve or the bend at the collet,  are we causing fatigue there? definately not.       
    • Yes, I do have the Seitz pivot gauge which is worth a small fortune these days. Got mine for about £200 which I thought to be crazy expensive at the time, but I've now seen asking prices over twice that. And no, I do not have the scaled pin gauge, but it would be convenient. Let me know if you find them! Anyway, the Seitz pivot gauge is in my opinion not really necessary if you have the JKA Feintaster. It can measure even the very small pivots w/o making any dents. One will have to be a lot more careful when using the Bergeon micrometres.
×
×
  • Create New...